When choosing between Starcraft and Bennington pontoon boats, consider your desired level of luxury and the activities you’ll be doing. Bennington positions itself as a luxury brand with a focus on high-end features and craftsmanship1, while Starcraft offers a wider range of price points and models catering to diverse needs and budgets, including fishing and watersports.
Here’s a breakdown:
Design and Layout
Bennington: Offers various layouts, including Quad Bench, Swingback, Stern Lounge, L-Bench, Entertainment, and Fishing4. They also provide a 3D design tool to visualise your ideal layout.
- Starcraft: Also offers diverse layouts, with models specifically designed for fishing, cruising, and watersports2. For example, the CX Fish series has livewells, rod holders, and ample gear storage3.
Performance
- Bennington: Focuses on “exceptional performance” through rigorous engineering and testing5. Specific details about engine options are not provided in the sources.
- Starcraft: Offers various engine options across its models. They also incorporate performance-enhancing features like the HMX third tube for increased stability and handling.
Features and Amenities
- Bennington: Highlights premium materials, ergonomic details, and a focus on comfort and luxury1…. They also offer a range of accessories and apparel9.
- Starcraft: Offers features like Soft Touch upholstery, Simrad touchscreen displays, extended decks, and Bimini tops10. Some models, like the SX, include high-end standard features such as the HMX Third Tube Performance Package and LED interior lighting.
Pricing
- Bennington: Pontoons range from $28,980 to $136,110, placing them in a higher price bracket. It’s worth noting that prices do not include destination fees.
- Starcraft: Pontoons start at $23,995 and go up to $122,995, offering more budget-friendly options2. Prices exclude trailers, freight, and dealer preparation6.
PROS AND CONS
Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons of Starcraft and Bennington pontoon boats:
Starcraft
Pros:
- Wide range of price points and models: Starcraft offers boats starting at $23,995, making them more accessible to budget-conscious buyers compared to Bennington. Their diverse lineup caters to various needs, from fishing to watersports.
- Focus on performance and innovation: Starcraft incorporates features like the HMX third tube and performance strakes for enhanced stability, handling, and fuel efficiency.
- Family-friendly features: Models like the EX and EX Fish series are specifically designed for families, offering affordability and features suitable for cruising and fishing.
Cons:
- May lack the high-end luxury feel of Bennington: While Starcraft offers features like Soft Touch upholstery, their overall focus might not match the premium materials and craftsmanship that Bennington emphasizes.
Bennington
Pros:
- Luxury and craftsmanship: Bennington is known for its premium materials, meticulous construction, and attention to detail, offering a higher level of luxury compared to Starcraft.
- Customisation options: Bennington provides a 3D design tool for visualising layouts and offers extensive customisation choices for features, accessories, and colours.
- Strong emphasis on customer experience: Bennington highlights its commitment to owner satisfaction, evidenced by their consistent CSI awards.
Cons:
- Higher price range: Bennington pontoons start at $28,980 and can go up to $136,110, making them a more significant investment than Starcraft.
- Less focus on specific activities like fishing: Although Bennington offers fishing layouts, their primary emphasis seems to be on luxury cruising and entertainment, while Starcraft provides dedicated fishing models with specialised features.
Ultimately, the “best” brand depends on your individual needs, budget, and desired level of luxury. Further research and a visit to a dealer can help you make the final decision.
